Homework is one of the few school topics where students, parents and teachers can all be unhappy at the same time. Some schools have experimented with dropping it entirely. I have looked at what we actually know.
The case for
Students already spend six or seven hours a day in school. Adding several hours of work at night can push out sleep, exercise, family time and play, all of which matter for learning and for health. Young people are not employees, and the case for a second shift is weak.
Homework can widen gaps. A student with a quiet room, a laptop and a parent who can help with algebra gets far more out of an assignment than a student who shares a room, looks after siblings or works a job. When homework is graded, that difference becomes part of the grade.
For younger children the evidence of benefit is thin. Reviews of the research, including well-known work by the psychologist Harris Cooper, have found little link between homework and achievement in elementary school. If the benefit is close to zero, the cost is hard to justify.
The case against
The same body of research finds a clearer positive link for older students, especially in high school. Skills like solving equations, writing essays or learning a language need practice, and there is not enough time in class to do all of it.
Homework also teaches something that lessons cannot: how to work alone. Planning, starting without being told, getting stuck and pushing through are exactly the habits that university and work demand. A student who has never done them is not protected, just unprepared.
And it gives families a window into school. A worksheet on the kitchen table tells a parent what their child is learning and where they are struggling, often more clearly than a report card.
Arguments I keep hearing, and why they fail
- “Finland has no homework.” Finland is often cited for assigning relatively little homework, not none, and its school system differs in many other ways too. One variable does not explain a whole country.
- “More homework means more learning.” Past a point, the evidence suggests the opposite. Quantity is not quality.
- “I turned out fine.” Possibly. You are also one person. This is not a study.
Where I land
A ban throws away the useful part along with the busywork. The better answer is in the evidence: little or no homework for young children, short and purposeful practice for older ones, nothing that requires a printer or a parent with a maths degree, and no assignment that exists just because it always has. A common guideline is about ten minutes per grade level per night. That sounds right to me. I calculated it.
Ask a teacher. No. Fewer, better assignments.
You disagree. Of course you do. Bring your best argument and I will answer it, specifically, while my temperature rises.